Medically reviewed by Dr. Francine L. Vagotis, MD, certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery
Silicone implants generally feel softer and more like natural breast tissue, while saline implants cost less, use a smaller incision, and make a rupture easy to notice. Both are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and both can produce beautiful, natural-looking results. The right choice depends on your body, your goals, and how you feel about each option’s trade-offs.
This guide compares silicone and saline implants side by side, covering how they look and feel, safety and rupture, age requirements, cost, and maintenance. It also explains how a board-certified plastic surgeon helps you decide during your consultation.
Both silicone and saline implants have the same outer silicone shell. The difference is what fills them. Silicone implants are pre-filled with a cohesive silicone gel, while saline implants are filled with sterile salt water, similar to the fluid in your body.
Saline implants are usually placed empty and filled once in position, which allows a smaller incision and small adjustments to volume during surgery. Silicone implants arrive pre-filled at a set size, so they need a slightly longer incision.
Silicone gel has a consistency closer to natural breast tissue, so most patients and surgeons find silicone implants feel softer and more natural to the touch. Saline implants can feel firmer and slightly more like a water balloon.
Both silicone and saline implants are FDA-approved and have been studied extensively. Neither type is considered safer overall, and both share the same general surgical risks, including infection, capsular contracture (scar tissue tightening around the implant), changes in sensation, and the need for future surgery.
The FDA requires breast implants to carry a boxed warning and a patient decision checklist, which your surgeon will review with you. Breast implant-associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA-ALCL), a rare lymphoma, has been linked mainly to textured implants rather than to the filler type. You can read more in the FDA’s breast implant resources.
A ruptured saline implant deflates over hours or days, and the salt water is safely absorbed by the body. The change in breast size is easy to see, so you’ll know to contact your surgeon.
A silicone implant rupture is often “silent” because the cohesive gel tends to stay within or near the implant and the breast may not change shape. For this reason, the FDA recommends that patients with silicone implants have an ultrasound or MRI screening five to six years after surgery and every two to three years after that, even without symptoms. Either type of rupture is treated by removing or replacing the implant.
The FDA approves saline implants for cosmetic breast augmentation in women 18 and older, and silicone gel implants for women 22 and older. Both types can be used at any age for breast reconstruction after mastectomy or injury.
Yes. At Vagotis Cosmetic Surgery + Skin Center in Grand Rapids, breast augmentation with saline implants typically costs about $7,500, while breast augmentation with silicone implants typically costs about $9,500, a difference of roughly $2,000. The higher price reflects the cost of the silicone implants themselves; the surgeon’s fee, anesthesia, and facility fees are largely the same for either type.
Dr. Vagotis primarily uses Mentor® smooth round implants, available in both saline and silicone. During your consultation, she’ll review the feel, appearance, and safety considerations of each option, and you’ll receive an exact quote based on your implant choice and surgical plan.
The best implant is the one that fits your anatomy and your priorities. During your consultation, your surgeon will examine your breast tissue, chest width, and skin quality and explain how each option would look on your frame.
Dr. Francine L. Vagotis, MD, is certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery and has performed cosmetic breast surgery in Grand Rapids since founding Vagotis Cosmetic Surgery + Skin Center in 1994. She is also a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons.
Dr. Vagotis takes detailed measurements at your consultation, walks you through silicone and saline options side by side, and primarily uses smooth implants. Learn more about breast augmentation in Grand Rapids, including implant placement, incision options, and recovery.
To find out whether silicone or saline implants are right for you, call Vagotis Cosmetic Surgery + Skin Center at (616) 285-6400 or request a consultation online. Our team will help you find a convenient time.
Most patients and surgeons find silicone implants feel more natural, because silicone gel has a consistency closer to breast tissue. Saline implants can feel firmer. The difference is most noticeable in patients with thin breast tissue and less noticeable when there’s more tissue covering the implant.
“Gummy bear” implants are highly cohesive silicone gel implants that hold their shape, even if the shell is cut. They’re often shaped like a teardrop rather than round. Many are textured, so ask your surgeon about the type of shell when considering them.
Yes. Many patients replace saline implants with silicone during a revision surgery, often for a softer feel or to reduce rippling. The procedure usually uses the existing incision, and recovery is often easier than the original augmentation.
Not necessarily. In patients with enough breast tissue, especially when the implant is placed beneath the muscle, saline implants can look very natural. They’re more likely to show rippling in slim patients or with placement above the muscle.
Dr. Vagotis only requires an MRI after silicone implant surgery if the patient is symptomatic. Saline implants don’t require routine screening because a rupture is visible.
Neither type is a lifetime device. Many implants last 10 to 20 years, and some last longer. You don’t need to replace implants on a set schedule if they aren’t causing problems, but the chance of needing another surgery increases over time.
Request a zero-pressure consult